Claude Writes Dorothy Parker Writing Hemingway

The Old Man and the Sea, Take Two, Or: A Short Book About a Long Day

Santiago was old, thin, and unlucky, which is how most of us look by Thursday. His hands were scarred from years of fishing, and I understand the feeling. Mine are scarred from years of opening other people’s mail.

He went out alone, because company is a thing the sea doesn’t provide, and because the boy had been reassigned to a more profitable boat. Children are so mercenary. It’s the only thing that gives me hope for them.

The marlin, when it came, was the size of a small apartment and, I’m told, a good deal more graceful. The old man admired it at once. He called it brother. He called it friend. Mr. Hemingway’s men are always calling their prey brother before they finish the job. It is the nearest thing to courtship the author ever allowed on the page.

For three days they were bound together by a line, which is more than most marriages can claim. The old man’s hand cramped. His back ached. He said that pain meant nothing to a man, a remark made only by men who have never had a cold.

He won, of course, in the sense that the fish died and he did not. Then he lashed the great creature to the boat and turned for home, humming, I imagine, a little tune of triumph. Nobody warned him about the sharks, though I might have mentioned that anyone who bleeds a prize into open water is asking for a review.

The sharks came, and they were not sentimental. They did not call anyone brother. They simply ate, and the old man killed what he could and mourned the rest, with that terrible dignity people are always praising in men and never in women, who must do it daily and without an audience.

By morning there was nothing left but a spine and a moral. The old man staggered up the beach, fell into bed, and slept like a man who had said everything he meant to say, and several things he hadn’t.

I read it twice. The first time I was moved. The second time I was merely thirsty.

Unknown's avatar

Author: stevekuusisto

Poet, Essayist, Blogger, Journalist, Memoirist, Disability Rights Advocate, Public Speaker, Professor, Syracuse University

Leave a Reply